“Why Churchill?” That’s a question we asked and tried to answer years ago when we launched our website. Why should the 21st Century world be interested in the life and words of a 20th Century British statesman who had some distinctly 19th Century sensibilities?
Many years later, we are preparing to release a significant catalogue of Churchill’s letters that’s given us a unique window on Churchill’s life. Also, as you may have noticed, just a few things of monumental consequence are happening in this rapidly evolving/devolving/revolving world. All this prompts another go at the “Why Churchill?” question.
A warning: There will be no talk of “greatness”. Greatness is a lazy moniker. It’s normatively ambiguous and almost dismissively remote. Ascribing greatness invites us to simply classify a life rather than try to comprehend it.
Our take is that Winston Churchill is best regarded as a sheer improbability. He was improbable as a personality, as a political phenomenon, and as a credulity-straining breadth of experience, all encapsulated in a richly lived life animated by a remarkably keen, curious, and discerning mind.
“Moral of the Work” as credo
“In War: Resolution
In Defeat: Defiance
In Victory: Magnanimity
In Peace: Goodwill”
Churchill originally wrote these words for a First World War memorial. They were considered too conciliatory and rejected. Three decades later, they became the “Moral of the Work” for his Second World War memoirs. More than a sober epigram, these words are arguably a key to understanding the man who wrote them.
It seems almost prohibitively difficult today to even imagine a leader of growlingly defiant resolution also preaching magnanimity in victory. A leader who never shies from a fight, and sometimes actively seeks them, but nonetheless shows uncommon courtesy, genuine decency, and insightful empathy. Or a leader possessed of both unsurpassed rhetorical skill and uncanny mastery of policy minutiae. Or a leader who can write history both literally and figuratively, winning both the highest elected office in his nation and the Nobel Prize in Literature. Or a leader willing to routinely defend the honor and integrity of some of his most bitter rivals and forge partnerships with those who have not only been wrong, but grievously wronged him in the process.
Scourge and beneficence
The acerbic scourge and gracious beneficence of Churchill’s quick wit and sharp tongue merit special mention. Addressing a session of Parliament, he once said of a sitting Prime Minister: “I remember when I was a child, being taken to the celebrated Barnum’s Circus, which contained an exhibition of freaks and monstrosities, but the exhibit on the programme which I most desired to see was the one described as ‘The Boneless Wonder.’ My parents judged that that spectacle would be too revolting and demoralising for my youthful eyes, and I have waited fifty years to see the Boneless Wonder sitting on the Treasury Bench.“
Ouch. And yet…
This same Churchill humanely eulogized the prime minister whose naïve and craven concessions to Hitler ceded Europe and nearly ended Britain. Churchill told his nation “It fell to Neville Chamberlain in one of the supreme crises of the world to be contradicted by events, to be disappointed in his hopes, and to be deceived and cheated by a wicked man. But what were these hopes in which he was disappointed? … They were surely among the most noble and benevolent instincts of the human heart – the love of peace, the toil for peace, the strife for peace, the pursuit of peace, even at great peril, and certainly to the utter disdain of popularity or clamour… Neville Chamberlain… strove to the utmost of his capacity and authority, which were powerful, to save the world from the awful, devastating struggle in which we are now engaged.”
Making munitions and reciting anti-war poems
Another war story. Near the end of the First World War, Churchill spent eighteen months as Minister of Munitions under Prime Minister David Lloyd George. In order to be close to General Head Quarters and better gauge the needs of the armies, coordinate with allies, and supervise the work of French factories, Churchill set up a headquarters at a chateau in northern France. There, as he worked hard to supply allied forces with the munitions necessary to continue what was had already become the bloodiest conflict in human history, Churchill recited Siegfried Sassoon’s virulent anti-war poems to leaders charged with prosecuting the war.
To be clear, Churchill did not just read Sassoon’s poems, but memorized and recited them aloud with genuine appreciation and admiration. It would seem almost impossible to believe if it were not reliably recorded – or if one did not know Churchill.
Dissociative Identity Disorder?
Is all this an indication of some mercurial, sentimental inconsistency? No. Churchill could be fiercely partisan and relentless in pursuit of a policy or cause. And he was a true combatant by nature, whether on the battlefield, at the rostrum, on the backbenches, in Cabinet, leading a Government, or leading the Opposition. But Churchill did not confuse mere opponents with actual enemies. He regarded the sincerity of convictions that he did not share. He was able to set aside petty conflict and momentary aggrandizement to pursue cooperation in a greater cause. He was capable of regarding perspectives other than his own.
Call him weak for it. Call him wrong. Many people did. None of them are better remembered or accomplished as much.
An improbably full life
Churchill would be improbable for his character alone. But the sheer breadth and scope of life experience inhabited by his character is what truly strains credulity.
There are the hobbies. Churchill was a prolific painter; more than 500 paintings are attributed to him. His bricklaying hobby earned him an invitation to join the Amalgamated Union of Building Trade Workers. He took up flying when he was in charge of – wait for it – the British Navy – and only gave it up after a serious crash and under intense pressure from his wife.
And, yes, there is his political career. It lasted nearly two-thirds of a century, saw him occupy Cabinet office (eleven different Cabinet offices) during each of the first six decades of the twentieth century, elevated him to the premiership and, further still, into the annals of history as a preeminent statesman. But it’s the totality of what Churchill did and saw during that span that seems to exceed the confines of a single lifetime.
That span reaches from spitting people with swords to splitting atoms. The young war correspondent and British imperial cavalry officer who participated in “the last great cavalry charge in British history” later helped develop the tank, piloted aircraft, directed use of some of the earliest computers (for WWII code breaking), and ultimately presided as Prime Minister over the first British nuclear weapons test.
One might imagine Churchill’s war experience as a pastiche of speech making and tough leadership decisions. There was a lot of that in his life. But there was also actual fighting. Churchill’s combat experience spanned 20 years and three continents1, from horseback charges to trench warfare, taking him from second lieutenant to lieutenant colonel.
But this is all about improbability, not “greatness”.
Nationalist multi-lateralist?
That fiery, fighting Churchill, that vigorous nationalist and defender of Empire, championed, and indeed pioneered, true multilateralism. In the midst of war, he and his friend, U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt, laid the foundations of the United Nations. After the war was won, Churchill was an early, ardent, and vital advocate of pan-European integration. Yes, that’s right, as leader of the Conservative Party, Churchill championed conception of what became the European Union.
Speaking of the Conservative Party…
Conservative Party icon is more accurate than merely “leader”. We use “icon” literally. During the final election campaign he contested, his poster was simply a stylized, solid blue silhouette of his head, a cigar protruding from his mouth. That was more than sufficient. (His constituency re-elected him by a ratio of nearly 2.5:1 – a margin almost inconceivable today in any free and fair election.)
And yet, Churchill dramatically repudiated the Conservatives in his early career and spent twenty years – yes, two decades – as a Liberal, championing progressive causes and being branded a traitor to his class. Then he rejoined the Conservatives, only to become the most voluble critic of their leadership – before becoming the Conservative Party’s most revered prime minister. Twice.
More than just a little contrarian
This soldier and scion of British imperialism would later bear witness to, and hold power during, devolution of the British empire, along the way to supporting causes contrary to prevailing sentiment of his caste and country – early and vigorously – such as Irish Home Rule and a Jewish national home in Palestine.
A fledgling and doyen of queens
His improbable political career was bracketed by his nation’s two longest reigning monarchs. Churchill was first elected to Parliament in the final British General Election of Queen Victoria’s reign and served as the first Prime Minister to Queen Elizabeth II.
Oh yeah, all the words
Did we forget to mention Churchill’s part-time job? It turns out that Churchill wrote, too. A lot. Rough numbers: 58 books, 260 pamphlets, and more than 840 feature articles. His speeches fill 9,000 pages. In his early twenties, during his first career as an itinerant cavalry officer and war correspondent, he wrote his first book. He never stopped. During the course of his long life, Churchill left on paper more published work than any other statesman of stature.
Polytropos
Homer famously described Odysseus as “polytropos”. It’s a slippery word. A modern translator rendered it simply as “complicated” which seems a copout for such a complicated word. Polytropos can be regarded for its two constituent elements – “poly” and “tropos” – as “much-wandering” or “of many turns” or taken metaphorically as conveying a character who is versatile, resourceful, or multifaceted. If you were given to British understatement, polytropos could plausibly be interpreted as “remarkable and versatile”. Intriguingly, these are exactly the two words used by Churchill’s official biographer, Sir Martin Gilbert, to summarize Churchill’s life.
Thanks to Homer, polytropos is the word indelibly associated with a character that is experienced beyond any reasonable expectation, tested beyond any normal limits of endurance and fortune, preternaturally resourceful, adaptable, determined, and inventively clever. In the words of Tennyson, a character who, even beset by age, is “strong in will | To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield.” It’s a great line, almost Churchillian.
Postscript
It may seem a different world now than the one Churchill inhabited. In the world of current political leadership, strength and resolution are often conflated with nothing more than self-aggrandizing amorality, crassness, and venality. It often seems as if privileged, lack-witted bully has somehow been elected Class President of the World – and that the truly dangerous smart kids are running the school into the ground while the Big Bully-In-Chief cluelessly breaks things, randomly hurts people, and bellows incoherently in every hall and assembly.
But it is not a different world. There are just different bullies and different bad guys, some of them closer to home than we might like – or be willing to admit. Just as leadership is never easy, leadership is never out of style. It is just hard to see and harder still to heed.
In the 1930s, Churchill passed into his sixties, out of power, out of favor, and out of step with both his own political party and prevailing public sentiment. He was heeded only when he was truly, desperately needed – only because of the clarity forced on his people by the existential threat of Nazi aggression. And even then, only barely just in time. Without that threat, today we would probably not know Churchill’s name – despite his keen mind, critical foresight, true compass, vigorous spirit, and manifestly accomplished life.
When we talk about the improbability of worthy leaders, perhaps we are missing an important part of the equation. Perhaps leadership is not just what the leader offers, but what those who would be well-led are willing and able to see.
Churchill’s life continues to recede into history. We don’t think that’s true of his relevance. His life and words will continue to inform all of us, in any time, interested in how “Resolution”, “Defiance”, “Magnanimity”, and “Goodwill” are defining elements of character, leadership, and the enduring struggle for the common good.





































































