The greatness improbability of Winston Churchill

“Why Churchill?” That’s a question we asked and tried to answer years ago when we launched our website. Why should the 21st Century world be interested in the life and words of a 20th Century British statesman who had some distinctly 19th Century sensibilities?

Many years later, we are preparing to release a significant catalogue of Churchill’s letters that’s given us a unique window on Churchill’s life. Also, as you may have noticed, just a few things of monumental consequence are happening in this rapidly evolving/devolving/revolving world. All this prompts another go at the “Why Churchill?” question.

A warning: There will be no talk of “greatness”. Greatness is a lazy moniker. It’s normatively ambiguous and almost dismissively remote. Ascribing greatness invites us to simply classify a life rather than try to comprehend it.

Our take is that Winston Churchill is best regarded as a sheer improbability. He was improbable as a personality, as a political phenomenon, and as a credulity-straining breadth of experience, all encapsulated in a richly lived life animated by a remarkably keen, curious, and discerning mind.

“Moral of the Work” as credo

“In War: Resolution
In Defeat: Defiance
In Victory: Magnanimity
In Peace: Goodwill”

Churchill originally wrote these words for a First World War memorial. They were considered too conciliatory and rejected. Three decades later, they became the “Moral of the Work” for his Second World War memoirs. More than a sober epigram, these words are arguably a key to understanding the man who wrote them.

It seems almost prohibitively difficult today to even imagine a leader of growlingly defiant resolution also preaching magnanimity in victory. A leader who never shies from a fight, and sometimes actively seeks them, but nonetheless shows uncommon courtesy, genuine decency, and insightful empathy. Or a leader possessed of both unsurpassed rhetorical skill and uncanny mastery of policy minutiae. Or a leader who can write history both literally and figuratively, winning both the highest elected office in his nation and the Nobel Prize in Literature. Or a leader willing to routinely defend the honor and integrity of some of his most bitter rivals and forge partnerships with those who have not only been wrong, but grievously wronged him in the process.

Scourge and beneficence

The acerbic scourge and gracious beneficence of Churchill’s quick wit and sharp tongue merit special mention. Addressing a session of Parliament, he once said of a sitting Prime Minister: “I remember when I was a child, being taken to the celebrated Barnum’s Circus, which contained an exhibition of freaks and monstrosities, but the exhibit on the programme which I most desired to see was the one described as ‘The Boneless Wonder.’ My parents judged that that spectacle would be too revolting and demoralising for my youthful eyes, and I have waited fifty years to see the Boneless Wonder sitting on the Treasury Bench.“

Ouch. And yet…

This same Churchill humanely eulogized the prime minister whose naïve and craven concessions to Hitler ceded Europe and nearly ended Britain. Churchill told his nation “It fell to Neville Chamberlain in one of the supreme crises of the world to be contradicted by events, to be disappointed in his hopes, and to be deceived and cheated by a wicked man. But what were these hopes in which he was disappointed? … They were surely among the most noble and benevolent instincts of the human heart – the love of peace, the toil for peace, the strife for peace, the pursuit of peace, even at great peril, and certainly to the utter disdain of popularity or clamour… Neville Chamberlain… strove to the utmost of his capacity and authority, which were powerful, to save the world from the awful, devastating struggle in which we are now engaged.”

Making munitions and reciting anti-war poems

Another war story. Near the end of the First World War, Churchill spent eighteen months as Minister of Munitions under Prime Minister David Lloyd George. In order to be close to General Head Quarters and better gauge the needs of the armies, coordinate with allies, and supervise the work of French factories, Churchill set up a headquarters at a chateau in northern France. There, as he worked hard to supply allied forces with the munitions necessary to continue what was had already become the bloodiest conflict in human history, Churchill recited Siegfried Sassoon’s virulent anti-war poems to leaders charged with prosecuting the war.

To be clear, Churchill did not just read Sassoon’s poems, but memorized and recited them aloud with genuine appreciation and admiration. It would seem almost impossible to believe if it were not reliably recorded – or if one did not know Churchill.

Dissociative Identity Disorder?

Is all this an indication of some mercurial, sentimental inconsistency? No. Churchill could be fiercely partisan and relentless in pursuit of a policy or cause. And he was a true combatant by nature, whether on the battlefield, at the rostrum, on the backbenches, in Cabinet, leading a Government, or leading the Opposition. But Churchill did not confuse mere opponents with actual enemies. He regarded the sincerity of convictions that he did not share. He was able to set aside petty conflict and momentary aggrandizement to pursue cooperation in a greater cause. He was capable of regarding perspectives other than his own.

Call him weak for it. Call him wrong. Many people did. None of them are better remembered or accomplished as much.

An improbably full life

Churchill would be improbable for his character alone. But the sheer breadth and scope of life experience inhabited by his character is what truly strains credulity.

There are the hobbies. Churchill was a prolific painter; more than 500 paintings are attributed to him. His bricklaying hobby earned him an invitation to join the Amalgamated Union of Building Trade Workers. He took up flying when he was in charge of – wait for it – the British Navy – and only gave it up after a serious crash and under intense pressure from his wife.

And, yes, there is his political career. It lasted nearly two-thirds of a century, saw him occupy Cabinet office (eleven different Cabinet offices) during each of the first six decades of the twentieth century, elevated him to the premiership and, further still, into the annals of history as a preeminent statesman. But it’s the totality of what Churchill did and saw during that span that seems to exceed the confines of a single lifetime.

That span reaches from spitting people with swords to splitting atoms. The young war correspondent and British imperial cavalry officer who participated in “the last great cavalry charge in British history” later helped develop the tank, piloted aircraft, directed use of some of the earliest computers (for WWII code breaking), and ultimately presided as Prime Minister over the first British nuclear weapons test.

One might imagine Churchill’s war experience as a pastiche of speech making and tough leadership decisions. There was a lot of that in his life. But there was also actual fighting. Churchill’s combat experience spanned 20 years and three continents1, from horseback charges to trench warfare, taking him from second lieutenant to lieutenant colonel.

But this is all about improbability, not “greatness”.

Nationalist multi-lateralist?

That fiery, fighting Churchill, that vigorous nationalist and defender of Empire, championed, and indeed pioneered, true multilateralism. In the midst of war, he and his friend, U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt, laid the foundations of the United Nations. After the war was won, Churchill was an early, ardent, and vital advocate of pan-European integration. Yes, that’s right, as leader of the Conservative Party, Churchill championed conception of what became the European Union.

Speaking of the Conservative Party…

Conservative Party icon is more accurate than merely “leader”. We use “icon” literally. During the final election campaign he contested, his poster was simply a stylized, solid blue silhouette of his head, a cigar protruding from his mouth. That was more than sufficient. (His constituency re-elected him by a ratio of nearly 2.5:1 – a margin almost inconceivable today in any free and fair election.)

And yet, Churchill dramatically repudiated the Conservatives in his early career and spent twenty years – yes, two decades – as a Liberal, championing progressive causes and being branded a traitor to his class. Then he rejoined the Conservatives, only to become the most voluble critic of their leadership – before becoming the Conservative Party’s most revered prime minister. Twice.

More than just a little contrarian

This soldier and scion of British imperialism would later bear witness to, and hold power during, devolution of the British empire, along the way to supporting causes contrary to prevailing sentiment of his caste and country – early and vigorously – such as Irish Home Rule and a Jewish national home in Palestine.

A fledgling and doyen of queens

His improbable political career was bracketed by his nation’s two longest reigning monarchs. Churchill was first elected to Parliament in the final British General Election of Queen Victoria’s reign and served as the first Prime Minister to Queen Elizabeth II.

Oh yeah, all the words

Did we forget to mention Churchill’s part-time job? It turns out that Churchill wrote, too. A lot. Rough numbers: 58 books, 260 pamphlets, and more than 840 feature articles. His speeches fill 9,000 pages. In his early twenties, during his first career as an itinerant cavalry officer and war correspondent, he wrote his first book. He never stopped. During the course of his long life, Churchill left on paper more published work than any other statesman of stature.

Polytropos

Homer famously described Odysseus as “polytropos”. It’s a slippery word. A modern translator rendered it simply as “complicated” which seems a copout for such a complicated word. Polytropos can be regarded for its two constituent elements – “poly” and “tropos” – as “much-wandering” or “of many turns” or taken metaphorically as conveying a character who is versatile, resourceful, or multifaceted. If you were given to British understatement, polytropos could plausibly be interpreted as “remarkable and versatile”. Intriguingly, these are exactly the two words used by Churchill’s official biographer, Sir Martin Gilbert, to summarize Churchill’s life.

Thanks to Homer, polytropos is the word indelibly associated with a character that is experienced beyond any reasonable expectation, tested beyond any normal limits of endurance and fortune, preternaturally resourceful, adaptable, determined, and inventively clever. In the words of Tennyson, a character who, even beset by age, is “strong in will | To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield.” It’s a great line, almost Churchillian.

Postscript

It may seem a different world now than the one Churchill inhabited. In the world of current political leadership, strength and resolution are often conflated with nothing more than self-aggrandizing amorality, crassness, and venality. It often seems as if privileged, lack-witted bully has somehow been elected Class President of the World – and that the truly dangerous smart kids are running the school into the ground while the Big Bully-In-Chief cluelessly breaks things, randomly hurts people, and bellows incoherently in every hall and assembly.

But it is not a different world. There are just different bullies and different bad guys, some of them closer to home than we might like – or be willing to admit. Just as leadership is never easy, leadership is never out of style. It is just hard to see and harder still to heed.

In the 1930s, Churchill passed into his sixties, out of power, out of favor, and out of step with both his own political party and prevailing public sentiment. He was heeded only when he was truly, desperately needed – only because of the clarity forced on his people by the existential threat of Nazi aggression. And even then, only barely just in time. Without that threat, today we would probably not know Churchill’s name – despite his keen mind, critical foresight, true compass, vigorous spirit, and manifestly accomplished life.

When we talk about the improbability of worthy leaders, perhaps we are missing an important part of the equation. Perhaps leadership is not just what the leader offers, but what those who would be well-led are willing and able to see.

Churchill’s life continues to recede into history. We don’t think that’s true of his relevance. His life and words will continue to inform all of us, in any time, interested in how “Resolution”, “Defiance”, “Magnanimity”, and “Goodwill” are defining elements of character, leadership, and the enduring struggle for the common good.


  1. Not counting North America, since he was only an observer in Cuba, even though he came under fire

Carl Sandburg

America’s 20th century proletarian troubadour poet Carl Sandburg (1878-1967) defied easy categorization. “The poet of the American vernacular was not only a tough, gregarious reporter, but a rollicking folk musician”. He wrote children’s books, worked as a Social-Democratic Party political organizer and aide, and became both a Hollywood advisor and State Department emissary. He was likely the only Pulitzer Prize winner to have been a bona fide, incarcerated, rail-hopping hobo, and remains the only Pulitzer Prize winner to have won awards for both Poetry and History. “Sandburg spoke to and for the American Century in which he lived and did his work.”

But before he did either, Sandburg’s itinerant youth included stints in the Army, college, a failed appointment to West Point (he failed the required mathematics and grammar tests), “chronic wanderlust,” and notional lecturing, before he rooted himself first in Wisconsin, and then in Chicago, the city he later covered as a reporter and celebrated as a poet.

His first volume of poetry, Chicago Poems, was published in 1916. “From the beginning, Sandburg the poet gave a powerful voice to the ‘people – the mob – the crowd – the mass’… He was quickly established as the poet of the American people, pleading their cause; reciting their songs, stories, and proverbs; celebrating their spirit and their vernacular; and commemorating the watershed experiences of their shared national life.”

In retrospect, it was fitting that Lincoln and Sandburg would find one another. His epic two-part, six-volume biography of Lincoln began as a commission for a juvenile biography and became instead among the most monumental and acclaimed biographies of America’s 16th President.

Complex is one word that could be appended to Sandburg. Contradictory is another. The poet obsessed with “the people” became a great biographer of greatness. He spent a substantial portion of his intellectual capital elevating and illuminating America’s most exalted president. The urban socialist became rural gentry. The man so indelibly associated with Midwest and the working class ended up living on a large farm in North Carolina for more than two decades. “Connemara” as he called his estate is sufficiently associated with his life and work to be preserved as a National Historic Site today.

The poet known for his gritty, unvarnished portrayals of working class life also wrote “zany, sometimes poignant American fairy tales for children” with such lyrical titles as Potato Face. Even Sandburg’s poetic canon is an odd contradiction. It won Sandburg both a trove of public awards and broad public acclaim. And yet, unlike his contemporary, Robert Frost, we don’t necessarily have specific Sandburg titles and lines that spring readily to memory. As poet Archibald MacLeish said at Sandburg’s memorial “with Sandburg it is the body of the work that weighs, the sum of it, a whole quite literally greater than the total of its parts…” More than any single verse or even voice, “Sandburg had a subject – and the subject was belief in man.”

In addition to his Pulitzers (1919, 1940, 1951), Sandburg’s long catalogue of accolades included the Presidential Medal of Freedom (1964), the Robert Frost Medal (1952) for lifetime achievement in poetry, election to the American Society of Arts and Letters, a bevy of honorary doctorates, the National Institute of Arts and Letters Gold Medal (1952), and an invitation to address a joint session of Congress (in 1959, for Lincoln’s 150th birthday). Sandburg’s 1967 own memorial ceremony was held on the steps of the Lincoln Memorial.

Spending the Summer

When I was a kid, summer was the eagerly-anticipated time of year associated with breaks – from school, from expectations, from the ever-accelerating, one-way conveyer belt that dumps us, unceremoniously, into adulthood. Now that I am an adult, and particularly since I became a parent, summer has become the opposite of what it used to be. When my daughter was still in primary and secondary school, summer was the time she was off, which meant I was on. But since I still had a job, making more time for her meant squeezing the same amount of work into late, odd hours. Summer became a time of disrupted, unpredicted schedules and less sleep.

Now that my daughter is 20, what once felt like a bit of a burden has become a privilege. I am entering the final week of the four she spent home from college – these the leftover, following the end of her summer job on the other side of the country and preceding her forthcoming term abroad adventure in Scotland. We have talked, cooked, played games, and worked out. We have shared things we’ve written and things we’ve read.  I have told her some of the same stories she has heard many times already. She has told me new ones, from her ever-more independent life. We have solved a few problems together, demonstrating both that Dad may still occasionally be useful and that Daughter is definitely increasingly capable. We have managed the friction inevitable when a young adult tries to fit themselves back into the house and role they occupied as a child.

All of that has held its own magic and might merit its own telling. But what I’m thinking most about as I write are the beach days. There have been Dad and Daughter beach days. A number of them. And those days have let us both spend a little time with the children that neither one of us is anymore.

So, some lines from this summer’s beach days, and my hope that your own summer held a little room for truancy and play.

Spending the Summer

These lines will eddy and settle
a sand-filled summer snow globe
clouded with the churn of the shore.

We will side step lapsing waves,
sunk to the knobs of our knees.
Eyes bent to the water, we are two,
twice as pale as egrets, unplumed.

We will find 28 sand dollars.
We both know it is ludicrous wealth.
On our beach day turned treasure hunt
we will ignore everything else in the water
that doesn't coin itself as obviously
as a fat-bottomed not-quite circle
center swelling its five-pointed star.

Finding will grow keener than credible.
A few will be no bigger than thumbnails,
sensed more than seen,
sieved in an almost-closed fist.
Many will be bare and bleaching,
the way ancient Greek temples are,
the way we think they were,
the way we keep conceiving them.
A few will still purple with life,
with bristles, or barnacles, or scars.
Most seat a palm's cupping hollow
just enough to make want of more.

While they are still precious few
we will space them, not touching,
on an inverted frisbee's makeshift altar.
They will become too many for such care,
piling like blown glass doubloons.
This August morning shares 75 years
between my daughter and her father.
Every new find will further divide our sum
until we are two children
who whoop and dart and imagine
our frisbee hoard back on the beach
raided by jealous beachcombers
or the indiscriminate greed of gulls.

They will dry and dull for days
in our kitchen window sun.
We will hold them one last time,
fingers gently cradling the edges
as we brush off the salt and shake
the fine, final sand from tiny navels
until they are as naked and light,
as easy to ruin as memory.

Knowing that September needs
to return my daughter
all of her years, and mine to me,
will urge the strange undertaking.
Preserving what we stole will fill a whole
eye stinging, sticky resin afternoon.
Silicone molds, made from sand,
will make keepsakes of spent summer
currency. Utterly uncovetous,
the molds contain and kernel all,
sand dollars, epoxy, irony,
and then, when it hardens, let it go,
enshrined, as seen and untouchable
as a glass-clear blink between waves.

Cheers!

“we said several things which now seem strange and significant” – An extraordinary collection of letters from Winston S. Churchill

On 30 November 2026, Winston Churchill’s birthday, we will release an extraordinary catalogue of thirty-one pieces of correspondence from Winston Churchill. More on the “extraordinary” claim in a moment. In recent weeks we just added the final few pieces, so this seems a good time to share – and maybe tantalize with – what we’ve been working on.

Extraordinary?

We just called the forthcoming catalogue “extraordinary” – a big word that we are using on purpose. Winston wrote a lot of letters during his long life. So there is never a shortage of correspondence by him on the world market. But letters that are truly remarkable (yep, another big claim) – remarkable for content, context, time, place, or some combination thereof – these are scarce. Such letters don’t just offer a few words and a signature; they offer singular perspective and insight on the writer, and a candid window on a specific moment in time.

The thirty-one letters in this catalogue span 24,530 of Churchill’s 32,927 days, more than 67 years of the 90 Churchill lived, from age 19 to age 87, from his as-yet-unproven youth to a time when Churchill passed “into a living national memorial” of the time he had lived and the Nation, Empire, and free world he served.

There are letters written from Churchill’s various homes – from his first bachelor flat to his beloved Chartwell. There are letters written from his many Cabinet offices – including the Colonial Office, Home Office, the Admiralty, the Ministry of Munitions, the War Office, and, of course, 10 Downing Street. But Churchill also writes from India, from New York, from Cairo, from Blenheim Palace, and from the trenches of Flanders. There are letters Churchill explicitly marked “Private”. There are letters that are not so marked, but perhaps should have been.

Churchill writes to close friends and allies, to women he’s courted, to prime ministers past and present, to commanding officers, to T. E. Lawrence “of Arabia”, to his King, and to a number of relatives, including his brother and his only female first cousin, “the nearest thing to a sister that Winston ever had”.

Across the thirty-one letters (and sometimes within them individually), there is an incredible range of tone, intention, and emotion. Churchill writes insightfully and incisively, mournfully and poignantly, desperately and pleadingly, confidently and stridently, playfully and humorously.  

Churchill writes about his regard for his beloved nurse. He writes about the fellow officer who died in his place on the battlefield. He writes – startlingly candidly – about the nature of religion, the unfolding disaster of the Dardanelles, and the injustice of immigration restrictions. He writes letters of both deepest condolence and personal exhilaration. During the First World War, he writes to his brother regretting that he is not part of the fight, and then, not much later, reports as a soldier serving on the Western Front. He accepts the resignation of an iconic hero. He taunts his publisher. He picks a literary fight with a literary giant. He puts a former wartime prime minister in his place during his fraught first weeks as wartime prime minister. He exults in the liberation of France. He declines to see Joan of Arc burnt. He uses the weight of his office and personal prestige to defend the honor of a friend. He indulges in race horses during his final years.

This is our most ambitious catalogue to date. Each item therein merited research, context, and descriptive attention. Hence each item receives more of an essay or monograph than mere description, including images not only of the document(s) being offered, but also of contextualizing people, places, and events. The catalogue will first be available electronically to those on our contact list, and more broadly thereafter. Click HERE to join our contact list. Print copies will be available for purchase.

How scarce?

How scarce is such a catalogue? Well, we’ve never seen a dedicated catalogue of Churchill letters quite like this. The last time we saw such a large, curated, life-spanning tranche of significant Churchill letters released on the market was a decade and a half ago, during the auction liquidation of much of the legendary Churchill collection of the Forbes family. It is worth noting that a number of the most compelling letters from that liquidation – the ones that actually sold, not the ones the Forbes family is still offering – will be found in our catalogue. There are also other treasures we have accumulated along the way – a mix of fortunate finds and material squirreled away in superlative collections that we’ve helped build over the years.

Why letters?

Perhaps no statesman left more of themselves on published paper than Winston S. Churchill. Today, we most often access and investigate Churchill’s life and legacy through the many published works he wrote and the many published works written about him. There’s no shortage of either. Not only is there a weighty, three-volume bibliography of published works by Churchill, but there’s also a bibliography of works published about him. And if that’s not enough, his official biography remains, unequivocally, the longest biography ever written.

What all this published work has in common is the limitations inherent to the very acts of drafting and editing, of expert input, careful consideration, and diligent preparation. Readying words for publication can dull and distance them even as they are polished. Deprive the immediacy of a moment or perspective. Leave the ink a little too dry on paper that’s just a bit too clean.

That’s why it may be that Churchill’s letters offer some of the clearest views of the man. Correspondence – by its nature more ephemeral, candid, and more distinctly in and of the moment than published works – can convey a vital sense of the correspondent. Letters, particularly the kind of letters you’ll find in this catalogue, can impart a vital sense of things that no acclaimed book or carefully crafted speech, however Churchillian in its mastery, can quite capture.

Moreover, letters speak to the complex compulsions that drive us to collect. For all the reasons stated above, letters address the curiosity and erudition that inspires and informs collectors. But collectors are not just amateur scholars; they are also trophy hunters. Letters offer the opportunity to have something truly singular – the sole copy of a unique encapsulation of moment and mind, ambered with ink and paper.

We look forward to celebrating Churchill’s birthday later this year by sharing this extraordinary trove of his correspondence with you.

Cheers!

Duff & Diana Cooper: “Bores with God’s help we will never be.”

Relentless curiosity was among the things we loved about Dick Marsh, who was taken from his family, friends, and beloved library in 2024. Dick’s collection held some superlative material of extravagant value, but he was no mere trophy hunter; his collection was just as likely to hold items worth only modest sums. All something needed to merit a place on Dick’s shelves was to be interesting, to have a story to tell, and, better, a story that Dick could research and savor. Dick was not the kind of guy to arrogantly leave his bookplate in his books. Instead, he’d leave his handwritten research notes, full of his citations, speculations, and questions.

Among his many collecting loves were Duff and Diana Cooper, each remarkable in their own right and, together, a “power couple” partnership influential in British politics and culture for three and a half decades.

DUFF COOPER

Sir Alfred Duff Cooper, 1st Viscount Norwich (1890-1954) was educated at Eton and Oxford, served with distinction during the First World War, and was elected to Parliament as a Conservative in 1924. He served as: Secretary for War (1935-37); First Lord of the Admiralty (1937-38); Minister of Information (1940-41); and Ambassador to France (1944-47). Cooper was married to Lady Diana Manners, a great beauty, successful actress, and scintillating hostess who both financially and socially enabled her husband’s political career. We’ll talk more about her soon. But Duff first. Cooper was knighted in 1948 and created Viscount in 1952, during Churchill’s second and final premiership. An author whose work spanned history, fiction, and verse, Cooper filled his “spare” time writing.

Much of Cooper’s political career was entwined with that of his friend, Winston Churchill. The two were friends for 40 years, having first met in 1914. Cooper’s regard for Churchill was both admiring and prescient. In March 1924, when the then-Liberal Churchill lost his seat in Parliament, Cooper wrote to him: “I know you have the lion’s courage which will enable you to make light of this cruel blow… there are a number of young and eager Conservatives whose enthusiastic support you command… They look forward to the time which cannot be far distant when you will be their inspired and inspiring leader.” Churchill officially rejoined the Conservative Party after a two-decade absence the next year, in 1925.

In 1929, both men suffered a serious political blow. Cooper lost his seat as a Conservative Member of Parliament in the 30 May 1929 General Election, which cost the Conservatives their majority and Churchill his position as Chancellor of the Exchequer, even though he survived his own reelection bid. Both men turned to literary purpose and to history, Churchill working on his biography of the First Duke of Marlborough while Cooper undertook his first book, a biography of the French diplomat Talleyrand, Marlborough’s contemporary.

In the 1930s, the two were fellow “Anti-appeasers” of Nazi Germany. Churchill’s “Finest Hour” would have to wait until 10 May 1940, when he finally became prime minister of a beleaguered Britain. Cooper arguably had his own “Finest Hour” in October 1938. He was dining with Churchill at the Other Club when it was announced that the Munich Agreement, Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain’s craven attempt to appease Hitler, had been signed. At the time, Cooper was First Lord of the Admiralty – the position Churchill had held from 1911-1915 and would hold again from late-1939 to mid-1940. The next day, Cooper resigned from the Government in protest. Cooper’s wife, Lady Diana, telephoned Churchill to tell him the news and later recalled in her memoirs how, as she spoke, “his voice was broken with emotion. I could hear him cry.”

Cooper would serve Churchill’s wartime Government. He would reach his own apogee when Churchill appointed him as Britain’s ambassador to newly liberated France. Cooper served in the role from 1944-1947, his success as Ambassador crowned on 4 March 1947 “by the signature of a treaty of alliance between Britain and France at Dunkirk.”

“Courage and joy in living were the most conspicuous features of his personality; if he had had less of either he might have achieved higher office but his life would have been far less fulfilled. He can fairly be accused of an extravagantly short temper, self-indulgence, and an inordinate appetite for wine, women, and gambling, but he was never mean or in the least ignoble; at times, indeed, he showed true nobility. He was a great-spirited patriot, too proud to court popularity, too reserved to command it readily, but a man whose honesty, generosity, and public spirit were never put in question.”

DIANA COOPER

To say that Diana Olivia Winifred Maude Cooper, Viscountess Norwich, known as Lady Diana Cooper, (1892-1986) was an actress, society hostess, and author is accurate in summation, but woefully inadequate. Likewise, Diana’s great beauty often eclipsed her cleverness and sense of humor. Born to privilege – officially to a marquess but possibly fathered by the brother of a Baron – Diana “received no formal education” but “learned much, including great drifts of poetry.” This shaped her prose, which was vivid, and her spelling, which was idiosyncratic.

Diana formally ‘came out’ in 1910 and participated in excess in her so-called “Golden Generation”, which lost much verve and many lives to the First World War. While Diana served as a nurse at Guy’s Hospital, several of her many suitors died in the fighting. Alfred “Duff” Cooper did not, prevailing both in battlefield heroism and against the opposition of Diana’s ambitious mother. They married in June 1919.

Acting, where Diana “gained the reputation of a hard-working actress as well as a transcendent beauty”, earned the money that enabled her husband to enter politics. Most notable was her role as Madonna in the play The Miracle. “This was first staged in the USA from November 1923 to the following May, and again for the following three autumns and winters. It toured Europe in 1927, and London and the provinces in 1932; the last performance was in January 1933. The Miracle was a phenomenal success, and Diana Cooper’s triumphant part in it was remembered as long as she lived.”

Acting eventually became secondary to her only son’s education and support of her husband’s career. During the 1930s she had “opportunity to display her outstanding talent as a hostess” though she was much more. During the Second World War, she supported her husband’s work in the Government of his friend, Prime Minister Winston Churchill, “even accompanying him to Singapore and the Far East against convention, and in the face of opposition.” Their zenith came when Duff became the first post-war ambassador to France. “With her remarkable ability to get on with people” Diana “collected a group of artists and writers” and “gave the embassy a glamour possessed by none other.”

Duff was created Viscount Norwich in 1952, but “Diana would have none of it, announcing in The Times that she wished to retain her former name and title, so Lady Diana Cooper she remained.” She and Duff had been together for 35 years when he died in 1954. She was “distraught without him” but filled her remaining 32 years with her son, grandchildren, friends, travel, and with the writing of her three-volume autobiography, “which was a resounding success.”

“A marriage which never staled.”

When Duff was courting Diana during the First World War, he told her “Bores with God’s help we will never be.” They weren’t.  It was not a conventional marriage. “Diana had many who loved her and Duff was frequently unfaithful.” Nonetheless, every indication is that they truly loved one another and made a tremendously dynamic and effective partnership. “It was a marriage which never staled… for each the relationship with the other remained the most important thing in their lives.”

A symbol speaks to both Diana’s place in Duff’s firmament and to their fulfilled commitment to never be bores– the bookplate that adorned the books in their library.

The bookplate was designed by the artist Reginald John “Rex” Whistler (1905 –1944) for the Coopers, his friends and patrons. The bookplate features a crowd of classical and modern elements representative of their shared life – champagne bottles, scrolls, despatch boxes, trailing grape vines. Tellingly prominent at the top center of the bookplate is a bust of Diana Cooper, portrayed as her namesake Roman goddess of the hunt, with a crescent moon diadem on her brow, a bow across her chest, and a quiver of arrows over her shoulder. Whistler wrote to Diana “I hope the bust of you isn’t too libelous – it looks haughty but I think busts SHOULD look rather haughty, don’t you”.

In some ways, Duff and Diana Cooper and the life they lived are a relic of a bygone era, rooted in the strange, evolving social dynamics of the 20th century’s Interwar era. In other ways, their combined dynamism and accommodating, mutually complementary partnership has more modern overtones. There is plenty of room for nuanced, retrospective consideration of the Coopers, but bores, certainly, they were not.

Cheers!

References: ODNB; Cooper, Old Men Forget; Cooper, The Light of Common Day; Ziegler, Diana Cooper; Gilbert, Winston S. Churchill; The Pol Roger Duff Cooper Prize

Spring Hawks

The hawks tell me it’s spring. This time of year I take out the spotting scope and set it up on a tripod in the living room, looking out the tall, south-facing windows. My backyard is on a finger canyon – which is to say one of a network of small, often interconnecting canyons, none of which would vaguely qualify as “Grand”. These are a staple of southern California topography, allowing an urban-wildland interface that often threads neighborhoods. “My” finger canyon separates my street from the next one to the south and harbors predators like raptors and coyotes, as well as many of the creatures that try not to be eaten by them. Some hundreds of yards across the canyon is a giant eucalyptus tree. High in a notch of that tree is a red-tailed hawk nest.

For most early springs during the quarter of a century I’ve lived here, a mating pair begins sprucing the nest in February and then, around this time, lays a clutch of eggs. I’ll set and focus the spotting scope so that the hawk’s nest nearly fills the ocular lense. Whenever the mood strikes us during the day, we’ll check in on how the next generation is progressing. It is a rite of spring. Maybe more than just a rite; it is also an important line of demarcation that the climate often refuses to clarify.

I was born in upstate New York and though my family moved to California when I was nine years old, I returned to upstate New York for college. Even though I’ve been in Southern California for part of my childhood and the vast majority of my adult life, I’ve never really acclimated to the fact that there is really only one season here. “Summer” is that one season. It lasts from roughly early March to early December. Summer means mostly sunny, relentlessly warm, and seldom rainy. The other season is “notquitesummer”, also known as “sometimescloudsorrain” or “maybeyoucanjustifyacoat”. It appears, sporadically, between mid-December to late February.

I recognize that what I describe is generally regarded as a virtue – one that drives an ever-expanding population and ever-increasing home values. I own that I’m oddly unappreciative. And yet here I am, fitfully resident, resistingly rooted, consistently contrarian.

I love the beach, but only when it’s cloudy and preferably windy, too, with a little gusted froth to the wave crests, when the sand cools rather than heats my bare soles. I don’t consider goofy, giraffe-necked palms to be real trees; a “frond” is no substitute for leaves that have the decency to hoard and spend color, relieve branches and then waiting patiently before greening them again. I’ll run on the sand, but never just sit there, beached and basking like some flippered mammal. I do not tan, but burn –  swiftly and to a witchy, Salem-burnt scarlet. I favor indoor sports. My vocabulary and diction do not accommodate “dude” or “bro” or “chill”. My little bonsai garden in the back yard contains only one species native to the region. I sell rare books in a place where regard for books often seems rare.

Here is what I do appreciate. Everything here is about borders and edges, hard-won increment and hardy privations. The topography can be sudden and sharply defined. There are the canyons and mesas of course. But there are also mountains – real mountains, more than twice as tall as the tallest U.S. peak east of the Mississippi – just a weekend morning’s drive away. If you’re intrepid, you can snow shoe a mountain pass and jet ski an ocean bay in the same day, which I did once just because I could.

And there is the sheer effort and endurance of the flora and fauna. There are few surfeits available to life. Plants intemperately hasten to green after rain because it is comparatively scarce. Green itself is not a vibrant ubiquity here, but a precious subtlety; one becomes attentive to the smaller differences between growing green and desiccating dun. As for unrooted things, almost everything that thrives – whether furry or scaled or feathered – obeys a muted sartorial color wheel of grays and browns and khakis. When nature does produce a vibrant hue it is stunning, a transfixing extravagance. Instead of forests, we have the troughs of arroyos, north-facing slopes, and other low points and lees where the moisture drawn from the sea and bestowed by cooler evening air can collect just a little more and a little longer, creating comparatively lush edens in topographical creases.

And there is, of course, the coastline. The constantly shifting, sedimentary southern California shore, with its ever-eroding cliffs and beaches. The tides push and pull at life from two different worlds, adjacent but apart. The soft roar and rock-rolling susurrus of the ocean constantly wooing and wearing. The sheer abundance of people and money and dwellings and enterprise in a place with only enough naturally occurring water to support maybe a tenth of the population that insists on being here – and that pays a hefty, average-salary-exceeding premium for everything from gas to groceries for the privilege.

The hawks are telling me it is spring. The mighty eucalyptus in which their nest resides helps track the accumulation of years. (The eucalyptus is no more native to this place than me, its progenitors brought here from even further away than me, and for even sillier reasons – a story for another day.) Roughly a third of the trunk circumference of this particular eucalyptus peeled away with the loss of a massive limb in a storm two decades ago. I did not expect the tree – over a hundred feet tall and precariously rooted halfway up the steep opposing slope of the canyon – to survive. But over the years, the bark has stubbornly, slowly reduced the loss from a gapingly wide, notionally mortal wound to just a terrible, ever-narrowing scar. It will not close in my lifetime. It will not close in the life of the tree. But each year the tree decides to stay. Maybe for the hawks. I keep watching. Sometimes I think I understand.

“Ulster will fight, Ulster will be right” – a hallmark letter, Irish Home Rule, and a tale of two Churchills

Much ink has been spilled on the relationship between Winston S. Churchill and his father, Lord Randolph Churchill. Churchill’s inclination to great reverential respect for his father seemed proportional to the cold distance Randolph held between them during his short life. But reverence was not obedient piety; Winston’s respect for his father did not prevent his developing his own perspectives on public policy during a political career which proved far longer, accomplished, and consequential than that of his father. Home Rule for Ireland is a case in point, underscored by an historically consequential letter we recently had the good fortune to handle, and which anchors and informs this post.

The letter is the infamously incendiary 7 May 1886 anti-Irish Home Rule declaration by Lord Randolph Churchill, containing and coining the rallying cry “Ulster will fight, Ulster will be right”. Excerpts from this letter were published the next day in The Times of London, fanning sectarian hatred and violence, and helping defeat the first attempt to grant Ireland self-government within the United Kingdom. The final, successful attempt would be pushed through Parliament by Randolph’s son, 36 years later.

It’s a lengthy letter, written entirely in Lord Randolph Churchill’s hand, on five 8 x 10 inches sheets of his “2 Connaught Place, W.” stationery, each sheet folded to form four 8 x 5 inches panels. Lord Randolph’s letter fills 17 panels. The letter is accompanied by the original, franked, “2 Connaught Place” envelope, hand-addressed to the recipient’s Glasgow address and signed “Randolph S. Churchill”.

Items often come to us shorn of knowledge about their ownership sojourn. In this case, we know at least quite a number of recent decades of stewardship; this letter was part of the Forbes family’s incomparable Churchill collection, thereafter part of the Churchill collection of Richard C. Marsh, from whence it came to us. Given the letter’s significance, it is no surprise that it was sought by such discerning collectors and part of such significant Churchill collections. We’ll soon offer this letter for sale, giving a new steward the opportunity to step forward. But first, this post!

“Ulster will fight, Ulster will be right”

The letter is dated “May 7th 1886” at the upper right, begins with the salutation “Sir“, and reads thereafter: “I have read your letter of the 4th May with great interest and I am obliged to you for the candour & frankness with which you convey to me your opinions on the state of public affairs as they are affected by Ireland and by the Irish policy of the present Government.”

There is plenty of substance to note. Some highlights include:

“…to demand from a Tory a pledge that he will never consent to the upset of the Union, as in other words to “Home Rule,” is as foolish superogatory, as to demand from a British Protestant that he will never consent to Establish and Endow in Great Britain the Church of Rome.”

“…Irish habits & customs may from time to time call for exceptional Legislative treatment. But these rare & minor incidents do not in any way detract from the sanctity of the great general overpowering principle of One Parliament one Law for the United Kingdom.”

Lord Randolph asserted that if Home Rule managed to become law, “the action of the Northern States of America from 1861 to 1865 would have to be the model for the action of the Tory Party under closely analogous peril, and that in a close imitation of American action in spite of every conceivable danger would be found the only method for the attainment of Imperial safety & the preservation of Imperial Unity.”

The referential justification of civil war would seem rhetorically charged on its own, but it is in the middle of the 15th page/panel that the fireworks really start. This is where the letter’s famously inflammatory peroration begins:

“If political parties and political leaders, not only Parliamentary but local, should be so utterly lost to every feeling & dictate honour & courage, as to hand over coldly, & for the sake of purchasing a short & illusory parliamentary tranquility, the lives & liberties of the Loyalists of Ireland to their hereditary & most bitter foes, make no doubt on this point, Ulster will not be a consenting party, Ulster at the proper moment will resort to the arbitrament of force, Ulster will fight, Ulster will be right, Ulster will emerge from the struggle victorious because all that Ulster represents to us Britons will command the sympathy & support of an enormous section of our British community, and also I feel certain will attract the admiration and the approval of free & civilised nations.“

The letter terminates with the two-line valediction “I have the honour to be | your obedient servant” followed by Lord Randolph’s signature “Randolph S. Churchill“. Professed obedient servitude is, of course, deeply ironic; this is not a trait for which either Randolph or his son is best remembered.

The moment

In 1886, Lord Randolph Churchill was a rising young force in his Conservative Party, shrewd, articulate, and influential, but an “awkward colleague” regarded by the head of his Party as possessed of a “wayward and headstrong disposition”. The narrow victory of the Liberals in the 1885 General election left them in need of support from Irish nationalists, causing Prime Minister Gladstone to espouse the policy of Home Rule. Lord Randolph “immediately appreciated the significance” and “decided to ‘play the Orange card’ – to exploit the strong opposition of Ulster Protestants to home rule.” In a fiery speech in Belfast in February 1886, Lord Randolph sought to rouse loyalist Protestant Orangemen of Northern Ireland. But it was in this published letter of 7 May 1886 to William Young that Lord Randolph committed even more volubly to his cause and truly fanned political flames.

A Scottish Liberal-Unionist member of Parliament, William Young (1863-1942) had written to Lord Randolph on 4 May to demand that he pledge never to support Home Rule for Ireland. Lord Randolph replied in this 7 May 1886 letter. Lord Randolph’s letter was no mere reply, but rather a political set piece; excerpts of the letter were published in The Times of London the next day and “electrified the nation with its threat of violence.”

It is the peroration of this letter that (altered only by salutary insertion of appropriate punctuation), Winston S. Churchill quoted at p.65, Volume II, of his 1906 biography of his father, Lord Randolph Churchill. In late April, Lord Randolph was facing a potential vote of censure. “Lord Randolph, however, persisted in his courses and, a few weeks later, in a letter to a Liberal-Unionist member, he repeated his menace in even clearer form.” Of the quoted passage in his father’s letter, Winston wrote “This jingling phrase, ‘Ulster will fight, and Ulster will be right,’ was everywhere caught up. It became one of the war-cries of the time and spread with spirit-speed all over the country. The attitude of the Protestant North of Ireland became daily more formidable. The excitement in Belfast did not subside. Dangerous riots, increasing in fury until they almost amounted to warfare, occurred in the streets between the factions of Orange and Green… Lord Randolph was, of course, the object of severe attack from the Irish party and especially from Mr. Parnell, who accused him of inciting, unintentionally, to murder and outrage.”

Characteristically, Lord Randolph “declined to recede in any way from his words” and his own Conservative party “jeered him loudly when he said so.” Prime Minister Gladstone himself intervened in the debate, sternly proclaiming of Lord Randolph “If we were a weaker country with less solid institutions, such occurrences as this would, in my opinion, have called for severe and immediate notice.” Lord Randolph wrote to Prime Minister Gladstone to point out alleged inaccuracies in the words attributed to him. This caused Gladstone to reply to Lord Randolph tartly on 21 May 1886, directly quoting Lord Randolph’s 7 May letter: “…I am content to take your opinions as you have yourself expressed them in the closing paragraph of your letter to Mr Young. Let us, then, if you please, consider that paragraph as already substituted for my words.” Irish nationalists and their leader, Parnell, denounced Lord Randolph for inciting violence and fanning sectarian hatred.

… A victory…

Lord Randolph’s inflammatory rhetoric from this letter helped sweep the Tories to victory in the July 1886 General Election, unseating Gladstone and placing Lord Salisbury at the head of a Government in which Lord Randolph became both Leader of the House of Commons and Chancellor of the Exchequer.

…and Defeat

But where Gladstone would return to the premiership (in 1892), Lord Randolph’s political career would be over by the end of 1886. Lord Randolph and Salisbury “shared a largely similar political ideology, but Salisbury lost patience with Churchill on a personal and tactical level.” When Lord Randolph submitted a posturing resignation on 20 December 1886 in protest over defence spending, Salisbury called his bluff and accepted. Lord Randolph was 37 years old. He would never hold Government office again, dying in January 1895 after the spectacular collapse of both his health and political career.

Aftermath and corrective echo

A quarter of a century after Lord Randolph Churchill wrote this letter – when his son, Winston, was the same age Randolph had been when he left the Government in 1886 – a strange, corrective echo occurred.

In the fall of 1911, Home Rule moved to the fore in political debate. Winston prepared to speak in the Ulster Hall in Belfast in favor of Home Rule – the very same hall where his father famously opposed Home Rule in 1886. “This was an anticipated, significant, and controversial event. Tensions were so high that the meeting was “transferred from the Ulster Hall which lay in the strongly Protestant area to a large marquee at the Celtic Road football ground in the Catholic working-class district.” History records that “Extraordinary precautions had to be taken to protect Churchill and his wife who had insisted on accompanying him. The Manchester Guardian reported that the railway line from Larne, where the Churchills landed in Ireland, to Belfast was patrolled by police to prevent sabotage.” The Churchills’ greeting was anything but friendly.

“A hostile crowd of nearly 10,000 greeted them outside the Grand Central Hotel in Belfast, where they were staying.” Of the drive from the hotel to Celtic Road, The Times reported “As each car made its way through, men thrust their heads in and uttered fearful menaces and imprecations.” The Manchester Guardian reported that “the back wheels of the Churchills’ car were lifted eighteen inches off the ground by the angry crowd before the police beat them off.” Churchill addressed a crowd of 5,000 Irish Nationalists, saying: “We look forward to a time… when the harsh and lamentable cry of reproach which so long jarred upon the concert of Empire will die away, when the accursed machinery, by which the hatred manufactured and preserved will be broken forever.” Remembering his experience in South Africa and in marked contrast to his father’s inflammatory rhetoric, Churchill said, “We have made friends with our enemies – can we not make friends with our comrades too?”

This was a dramatic generational turn – and a dramatic turn for Winston Churchill as well. The younger Churchill had inherited his initial views about Ireland from his father. On 6 April 1897, three and a half years before his first election to Parliament, the young Winston wrote to his mother “Were it not for Home Rule – to which I will never consent – I would enter Parliament as a Liberal.” In May 1904, Churchill broke with his father’s Party, crossing the aisle to become a Liberal.

It has been asserted that Winston’s experience during the Boer War – as a journalist, combatant, prisoner, and fugitive – gave him some sympathy for Irish concerns. Certainly, by the first time he ran as a Liberal, his father’s hard line against Home Rule had begun to soften in Winston. And it also seems plausible that his initial stints in Government, including as Undersecretary of State for the Colonies (1905-1908), further informed his perspective. By 1911, his position had reversed entirely.

The Home Rule crisis of 1912-1914 was sidelined by the outbreak of the First World War. But on 16 February 1922, as Britain’s Secretary of State for the Colonies, Winston S. Churchill introduced the Irish Free State Bill, and pressed successfully for its swift passage, formally establishing the Irish Free State as a self-governing dominion within the British Commonwealth.

One might fairly point out that Churchill’s evolved, expansive view on Irish self-government contrasts sharply with, say, his views on Indian independence. But that is another topic for another post…

Cheers!

References: Gilbert, Vol. II; Churchill, Lord Randolph Churchill; ODNB; Hillsdale College, The Churchill Project

Lovely, Dark and Deep – A Catalogue of Robert Frost

We are excited to release our new catalogue, which focuses entirely on iconic American poet Robert Frost. You may download the full catalogue by clicking HERE or on any of the images in this post

Assembling the trove of Robert Frost material in this catalogue was the work of decades. Herein, 71 items signed or inscribed by Frost, spanning his first to his final published work – including nearly three quarters of the bibliographer’s “A” list1 of his books and pamphlets published during his lifetime. And, of course, more besides, including signed letters, Christmas cards, manuscript and souvenir poems, and even a legal document.

Robert Lee Frost (1874-1963) won the Pulitzer Prize for Poetry four times (1924, 1931, 1937, and 1943), a feat still unrivalled to this day. He spent the final decades of his life as “the most highly esteemed poet of the twentieth century” with an accumulating hoard of academic and civic honors, including honorary degrees from more than forty colleges and universities. (So many that the various academic hoods that came with the degrees were sewn together to make a quilt! And leading Frost, who never graduated from college, to quip “I got my education by degrees.”) Two years before his death, Frost became the first poet to read at the inauguration of a U.S. President. (Yes, back when American presidents were literate…)

But that’s just biography.

In a 15 November 1930 lecture called “Education by Poetry,” Frost said that “Poetry provides the one permissible way of saying one thing and meaning another.” As it happens, this is also a functional definition of irony, and the life of Robert Frost contained some delicious ironies.

The quintessential poetic voice of New England was actually born in San Francisco. And this great Yankee poet, Robert Lee Frost, owes his middle name to his father’s hero, Robert E. Lee, the General-in-Chief of the Armies of the Confederate States during the Civil War. (No surprise that you’ll not see his middle name in his signatures – except for Item 48 in this catalogue.)

Then there’s England – the old one, not New. This iconic American poet had to move to England to achieve publication and recognition. Only after his first two books were published in England did Henry Holt and Company agree to publish his books in America. Holt would proudly remain his American publisher for the rest of his life.

And there’s the middle-aged man with a boy’s will. Frost was nearly forty years old before his first collection of poetry (A Boy’s Will, 1913) was published. Despite this late start, he would get to enjoy half a century of increasing and, eventually, unequalled fame and recognition.

Frost is often recognized for his accessible language and command of colloquial speech. Both were an intentional affectation, belying not only the complexities of his conceptions, but also the remarkable erudition and “fierce intelligence” of a man who spent decades lecturing and teaching at some of America’s most elite colleges and universities.

How does Yankee diction and purported provincialism square with Frost’s enduringly broad appeal? New England is a launching point, not a limitation. Frost’s apparent parochialism is exhaustively expansive. “New England is taken as representative… Frost moves through the local into the universal.”2 Or, as a fellow poet wrote, one sees in Frost’s work “Universal experience, portrayed concretely, in locality, in Yankee accent.”3

And sentiment. So well-known and beloved are many of Frost’s poems that we quote them to one another to express our feelings, amplify our own experience of love and loss. Yet Frost conspicuously avoided personal sentimentality in his poetry, which is often curiously, beautifully aloof. “Something in me refuses… to use grief for literary purposes. When I care less, I can do more.” Frost’s poetry is capable of deeply touching its readers, and yet you will not find poems about his father’s alcoholism, his sister’s and children’s mental illness, the death of his wife from cancer, and the deaths of four if his six children from cholera and childbirth and suicide.

Here, in Southern California, just reading Robert Frost can seem an exercise in irony. Here it’s likely that the only precipitation a big winter coat will endure is sweat. And kicking palm fronds in your sandals is just not the same as shuffling booted feet through mounds of mouldering leaves. But even if our woods here are never “lovely, dark and deep”, there is Robert Frost. His New England provides us with culturally universal visions of reaving and renewing, of all seasons, literal and figurative. And Frost remains the elemental poetic voice of these seasons, the “wind’s will” synonymous with “A boy’s will,” baring branches with brisk, gusting whorls of ink and leaving crisp, listening silences between.

May you enjoy perusing this catalogue as much as we enjoyed compiling it. More important, may you grant yourself the gift of some time with Frost’s words and perspective.

Cheers!

1 Joan St. C. Crane, Robert Frost: A Descriptive Catalogue of Books and Manuscripts, A1-A42

2 Jay Parini, Robert Frost: A Life

3 “Genevieve Taggard, Robert Frost, Poet,” New York Herald Tribune Books 30 November 1930

An accomplished winner of maybe the worst award ever

I mean no disrespect to some of the fine actresses who have earned the distinction, but whatever my daughter (yes, an intended audience for this post) chooses to become in life, I hope it is not a “Best Supporting Actress.” As we were cataloguing a Winston Churchill letter from 1945 this week, it occurred to me that “Best Supporting Actress” might be the worst award ever. Yet, for most of history, and even still in a lot of places in the world, it feels like “thanks for helping me look good” was the most recognition women could expect. Which brings me to Ava Courtenay Anderson, formerly Ava Wigram, nee Bodley, and eventually Viscountess Waverly (1895-1974) – an extraordinary woman I’d never have known about if not for her first husband, Ralph Wigram, and her friend, Winston Churchill. Another potential female Atlas relegated to “supporting.”

And the Best Supporting Actress Award goes to…

After her parents’ 1908 divorce, Ava lived chiefly in Paris with her father, “who made certain she was formidably well read, had a deep respect for culture and literature, and a very retentive memory.” This training and education coupled with “self confidence and… good looks” made her a complementary partner to the man she married in 1925. Ralph Follet Wigram (1890-1936) was a “talented but shy diplomatist,” then “a high-flyer” in the British embassy Paris. Ava “soon established an influential social circle, despite her anxieties about Wigram whose health was permanently impaired from 1927 by an attack of polio and about their only child, Charles, born severely disabled in 1929.”

When Wigram was recalled to London in 1933, their diplomatic partnership took on global implications. In 1933, future Prime Minister Winston S. Churchill was out of power and out of favor, his growing concern about the rise of Nazi Germany at odds with both the British government and prevailing public sentiment. Ava and Ralph shared Churchill’s concerns, and in 1934 Ralph began supplying Churchill with secret government information, including about German rearmament, for Churchill to use to harry the Government and rouse the public.

This image, taken by Ava, captures her husband and Churchill at Chartwell in 1935.

Enter Pierre Etienne Flandin

The apex of Ralph’s and Ava’s efforts came in March 1936.

On 7 March 1936, Nazi Germany’s troops reoccupied the Rhineland, in violation of the Treaty of Versailles. It was a test of British and French resolve. A few had the foresight to understand that this was the last, least costly opportunity to stop Hitler before war became an inevitability. Those few included Ava, Ralph, Winston, and the French Foreign Minister, Pierre Etienne Flandin (1889-1958), who had briefly served as France’s prime minister from November 1934 to June 1935.

In March 1936, Flandin visited London to attempt to galvanize British support for decisive, immediate, combined Franco-British action to resist Hitler’s aggression. There he found staunch allies Ralph and Ava Wigram.

Wigram “thought it was within the compass of his duty to bring Flandin in touch with everyone he would think of… from the press, and from the Government…” to hear Flandin’s exhortations. The Wigrams hosted meetings – and even a press conference – with Flandin at their London home. The British Government steadfastly refused to act, summed by Lord Lothian’s cavalier dismissal of Nazi ambitions: “After all, they are only going into their own back-garden.”

Terrible vindication and a trial

In the aftermath, things went poorly for the Wigrams, for Churchill, and for Flandin.

Ralph Wigram took the failures of the French and British governments deeply personally and died, suddenly, in December 1936. Churchill, who attended his funeral and gave a luncheon at Chartwell for the mourners, praised Wigram’s “profound comprehension” and regarded his “untimely death” an “irreparable loss”.

Churchill remained largely politically impotent for the rest of the decade, cursed like a proverbial Cassandra with the ability to see what was coming, but not to alter the course of events. Only the terrible vindication of the outbreak of the Second World War returned Churchill to the Government in September 1939 as First Lord of the Admiralty. He became beleaguered Britain’s wartime prime minister in May 1940.

After Ralph Wigram’s death, Churchill reported that Ava was bereft and “all adrift now. She cherished [Wigram] and kept him alive. He was her contact with gt. affairs.” Now she was a widow with a severely disabled son. Nonetheless, “Ava was able to carry on… opposition to Nazism and to flourish as a hostess at her home, 4 Lord North Street, Westminster, near parliament and Whitehall. Playing to her strengths as an informed and well-connected society figure, she created an environment valued by many senior diplomats and politicians.” That was how she met Sir John Anderson (1882-1958), who became her second husband in October 1941, during the Second World War. More on that later.

The horror of the Second World War they had tried to prevent at least provided some measure of vindication and renewal for Ava and Winston. It ruined Flandin. In June 1936, shortly after his failed effort in London, he lost his post as French Foreign Minister. Drawing perhaps the wrong lesson after the Munich concessions to Hitler in 1938, Flandin expressed support for appeasement. After France’s subjugation by Nazi Germany, collaborationist Vichy chief of State Phillipe Petain appointed Flandin Foreign Minister and Vice-Premier on 13 December 1940. Flandin occupied those positions only until 9 February 1941. Despite his extraordinary mid-1930s efforts to stop Hitler, Flandin was arrested and imprisoned by DeGaulle during the war, and after the war tried by the retrospectively-righteous French.

Oh, right, there was a letter…

And here is where our letter comes in – the letter that introduced us to Ava and prompted this post.

This is a 24 November 1945 typed letter signed by Winston S. Churchill to Lady Ava Anderson, his friend and stalwart 1930s anti-appeasement ally, providing her with a copy with his 14 November 1945 letter to former French Prime Minister Pierre Flandin defending him against charges of treason for his actions during the Second World War. Together, these two letters are significant testimony to Churchill’s principled loyalty, his willingness to take stands contrary to prevailing public sentiment, and his moral inclination, as he would state in his Second World War memoirs, to “In victory: magnanimity”. They are, of course, also testimony to the respect and regard Ava had earned from her friend, Winston.

The letter to Lady Anderson is typed on a single sheet of Churchill’s Chartwell stationery, with his “28, Hyde Park Gate” address typed at the head. After his warm salutation “My dear Ava,” Churchill writes “You may be interested to see the letter Flandin wrote to me and the reply which I have authorized him to make use of. I do not expect it will make me very popular in France, but I know you will be in sympathy with it.” Churchill closes with his autograph signature and valediction “Winston S. Churchill”. Appended are four sheets on thin stock comprising an apparent carbon copy of Churchill’s 14 November letter to Flandin. The copy of the letter to Flandin bears a secretarial duplication of Churchill’s autograph salutation and signature.

This item is offered for sale HERE on our website.

Flandin asked Churchill to write a letter on his behalf for submission to the court. This Churchill, did, in a letter that is an extraordinarily piece of exculpatory presentation, carefully constructed to credibly align and exonerate Flandin’s actions, without any undermining misrepresentation, hyperbole, or disrespect to the authorities with power over Flandin’s fate.

Churchill’s letter to Flandin opens by discussing Flandin’s 1936 “endeavors to bring about a more decisive joint action” between Britain and France. Aware that his own status as an early and ardent opponent to Nazi Germany was beyond dispute, Churchill refers to his and Flandin’s efforts to thwart Hitler as “we” and “in common”. More delicately handled is Flandin’s congratulation of Hitler on “the peaceful settlement” after Munich, in which, Churchill rightly points out, Flandin was “supported by very large majorities on both sides of the Channel”. Churchill handles Flandin’s short tenure as Vice-Premier and Foreign Minister in the Vichy government by saying “I was glad. I thought to myself ‘here is a friend of England in a high position…’ I also thought that the Germans would have you out. This is exactly what happened…” Churchill substantiates this interpretation: “I have heard that in your period of Office, you managed to stop an expedition being sent from Dakar against the Free French centre at Tchad…” which “would have added greatly to the troubles which General de Gaulle and I were facing together”. This was a particularly intentional alignment; over Churchill’s strenuous objections, de Gaulle had imprisoned Flandin in 1943. Churchill’s political history is replete with examples of his working with, and often befriending, those who differ with him if he believes in their integrity and intention. In closing, Churchill makes this plain: “I have always regarded you as on our side and against the common foe and his collaborators… I feel I should be failing in a duty of friendship… if I did not set forth the facts as I saw them…”

Churchillian friendship proved Flandin’s salvation. With Churchill’s permission, Flandin used Churchill’s letter in his defense and it reportedly “caused a considerable stir when read out in court.” On 23 January 1946 the charges against Flandin were dropped and he was released from custody.

That Churchill shared this letter with Ava 10 days after he wrote it testifies to the regard in which Winston held Ava, and of their shared efforts to prevent the Second World War.

Ava’s aftermath

Ava’s “Best Supporting Actress” role saw a sequel. Her second husband, new Member of Parliament John Anderson, was “an aloof, self-contained widower” who “never saw colleagues at his home and seldom invited guests to lunch at his club.” Once again, “Ava was gifted with the personal skills that her husband lacked.” She “supported his cabinet career” when he became Winston Churchill’s Chancellor of the Exchequer in the final years of the Second World War “and she continued to entertain despite the stresses of war.” To his credit, her husband “helped in turn to alleviate the heavy responsibility of caring for her son, Charley Wigram, who died in August 1951.”

After the war, Ava “was in her element in social and promotional activities as wife of the chairman of both the Port of London Authority and the Covent Garden Opera Trust during the period of post-war austerity and reconstruction.” Following her husband’s elevation to the peerage in 1952, Ava was known as Ava, Viscountess Waverly.

“Ava… was more than a personable adjunct to her able but socially awkward spouses. A background including entrepreneurial grandfathers, and erudite father, a detailed knowledge of French diplomatic affairs, and strong affinities with politicians, together with good organizing ability, enabled her to direct her hospitality toward practical ends. She created for herself a role over four decades as a highly regarded hostess in political and cultural circles.”

Despite a respectable general knowledge of history, if I’d not had occasion to research this letter, I’d not have known about Ava.

The enduring bond between Ava and Winston

The good news is that someone far more important than you or me, reader, knew and appreciated Ava. “Winston was devoted to Ava for the rest of his life, as she was to him. Ava had taken a photograph of Winston and Ralph Wigram walking on the grounds of Chartwell. Winston signed it and Ava inserted a press cutting of Winston’s June 18, 1940 ‘finest hour’ speech. This framed photograph stood at her bedside until her death in 1974.”

Cheers!

Churchill Book Collector

References: Marsh, Churchill, Flandin, and Wigram: The Rest of the Story; Gilbert, Vol. VIII; Churchill, The Second World War: The Gathering Storm; ODNB; Hillsdale College: The Churchill Project

ORDER THIS TERRIFIC NEW BOOK!

We unabashedly urge you purchase a book that we are not even offering for sale.

Our friend, wonderfully erudite fellow Churchill collector (and physician, and medical researcher, and corporate executive, and writer, and just generally interesting and accomplished gentleman) Gary Stiles, has written an absolutely terrific book about an absolutely terrific book. A Prelude to Immortality: Churchill’s My Early Life. To quote the publisher, “This is the incredible story of why and how Winston Churchill in his mid-50s decides to write an autobiography.”

Gary did the Churchill world a great service a few years back with publication of Churchill in Punch – a lovely book, too, that should be on the shelves of anyone interested in Churchill. But back to A Prelude to Immortality… We had the privilege of an advance review copy and Gary was kind enough to ask us to provide a pre-publication review blurb. Here’s what we had to say about the book:

“Most of what is written about Churchill just tells us who he was and what he did. Stiles shows us how and why Churchill became who he was. In Stiles’s hands, Churchill’s single most popular work not only entertains the reader, as it has done for nearly a century since it was first published, but now illuminates its author as never before. Stiles brilliantly uses Churchill’s own – and only – retrospective on his origins as a kind of skeleton key to access Churchill’s voice and vitality, his animating attitudes and ambitions. A true sense of Churchill ramifies and resonates in these pages. Not only has this never been done before, but it is hard to imagine it being done better. A Prelude to Immortality is silver-tongued scholarship – part rigorous analysis, part reference compendium, all held within a gripping narrative.”

Folks, there’s no hyperbole in what we wrote. But just in case you don’t believe us, here’s what historian Andrew Roberts, author of the superb biography Churchill: Walking with Destiny, has to say:

“This fascinating biography of a biography essentially explains to the reader how Winston Churchill’s thought process worked when he wrote My Early Life, one of the books that deservedly won him the Nobel Prize for Literature. A vital part of the Churchill myth as well as being a beautiful piece of writing in itself, My Early Life has always been something of an enigma – until now.”

A Prelude to Immortality can be pre-ordered HERE in the U.S. Amazon – but won’t be delivered until early January. If you need the book before Christmas, HERE it is in UK Amazon.

Cheers!